Some of the Field Camp members. L to r, "Merrily" Sturges, Robert Needem, Jerry (Merv) Bartholomew, Mitchell Smith, Bob Gardner, Rob Scholten, Larry Ramspott, Mrs. Ramspott, T.K. Reeves, Ron Bartrie, and Lynn Brant (T.A.). Thanks to David Reidenour for the photo and the identifications.
Field Camp 1963
Students
In 1963 the Geological Sciences Curriculum included Departments of Geology, Geophysics-Geochemistry, and Mineralogy. GSc 470, Introduction to Field Geology, was taught during the academic terms, and Field Geology (GSc 472) was taught as a summer course in the West. It is unclear, from the University General Catalog, which majors were required to take GSc 472, but probably geophysicists were not. Thanks to Jerry Bartholomew for the 1963 names.
Faculty
Rob Scholten (left), Larry Ramspott (PhD62; faculty, University of Georgia), Larry Lattman (cross-country)
TA
Lynn A Brant (MS71, DEd80)
Where They Stayed
Little Sheep Creek Campground west of Lima, Montana (Lima to left)
Main Projects
Mapping in the Tendoy Range
Jerry Bartholomew's recollections about the 1963 field camp, with some additional comments by Lynn Brant and David Reidenourt
Jerry Bartholomew's Recollections of the 1963 Field Camp (Jerry still teaches at the Penn/YBRA Field School), with additional comments by Lynn Brant
I went to field camp in 1963. Rob Scholten taught the camp that year with Larry Ramspott, who was then an Assistant Professor at the University of Georgia, as his assistant, and Lynn Brant, who had been at the camp the previous year, as TA.
Different groups of 3-4 drove the vehicles out. Lynn Brant was in our vehicle. We stayed one night at "Wendt," SD at a ranch where they had stayed the previous year [see Lynn Brant's story on the 1962 webpage]. The ranch was quite large, but the owner could neither read nor write (except his name), and his spouse did not want any of those oil rigs on their property. Their living room had a walk-in stone fireplace, where you could place large logs, and then a sunken area in front of it, and a wide stairway that went to the second floor. We then drove west and over the Bighorns (and had our first snowball fight) before arriving at YBRA. I believe that it was the 4th of July when we were collecting feldspar crystals (which I still have) from a granite in the Beartooths when we got a blizzard that dropped about 7-8" of snow before we got back to YBRA.
We collected near YBRA and then spent a couple of days touring the Beartooths, Yellowstone, and Hebgen Lake on our way to Lima, Montana. We spent most of our six weeks camped at the campground on Little Sheep Creek near Lima; we typically had Sundays to go into Lima. There were about 10 of us there, along with a couple of graduate students who were working in the area (the names of Donovan B Kelly and Robert W Hall from the 1962 camp list both look familiar). One of the grad students got sick and stayed in the Lima Hotel for a while. [See Lynn Brant's recollections below: that was actually Don Kelly, an undergrad.] Another graduate student was a tall, thin guy [Herm Witte: read Bob Gardner's story] who put wheat germ on everything and constantly bragged about how much he could eat, until one day I came back hungry: he had 7 burgers without buns, so I had 8 burgers with buns and toppings!
Each student pair had a block of the Tendoy Range to map using air photos. Our base maps only contained ridgelines and streams, so all mapping had to be done on the photos. We completed a map, cross section, and report, usually by the light of a gas lamp in the tent to stay warm enough to work in the evening. My map wasn't too bad. I started working in that area again in 1983 when I joined the Montana Bureau of Mines & Geology at Montana Tech and have continued to do work there.
My partner was Mitch Smith (who was wounded in Vietnam; I later ran into him in the late 60's in southern California). Mitch and I were assigned a 28 square mile area west of Dell, Montana that was the northernmost of the five areas and included Timber Butte Mtn and Dixon Mtn to just south of Big Sheep Creek. Bob Gardner (who later joined the faculty at the University of South Carolina) partnered with Dave Reidenouer (who I believe later worked for the PA Survey) to map the the adjacent area to the south between Big Sheep Creek and Little Sheep Creek. T K Reeves and Mary had the next area to the south, which they could walk to from the camp on Little Sheep Creek. Another team was farther south in an area that included Garfield Mtn (the highest peak in the area) along the continental divide.
One of the short day-projects that we had to do was to sketch the "wailing wall" along Big Sheep Creek (sec.15, T14S, R10W). My original sketch in 1963 was not very good, but I redid the sketch and analyzed the outcrop for the 1989 Tobacco Root Geological Society meeting in Dillon, so other field-camp people can see it again today in: Northwest Geology, volume 18, p.33. They may also recognize the outcrop with folds about 2 miles west of the Red Rock fault scarp on Big Sheep Creek (sec. 25, 36, T13S, R10W) on p.27, and the Red Rock fault scarp, which we trenched, near the road to camp on Little Sheep Creek (p.23).
Rob's spouse [Marsha] cooked our meals for us, and I believe that his son was there as well. Rob took us to Dillon one evening for a steak dinner; we visited Bannock; some of our group participated in the cow-milking contest at the Rodeo in Dillon; we took a two day trip to see volcanics in Idaho; and at the end of the camp, we took a trip to Butte and Anaconda and Glacier National Park. On the trip to visit volcanics in Idaho, we climbed up a steep slope of volcanic material and I remember that Rob was surprised that I climbed it faster than he did, but not by much. (Of course nowadays at YBRA there are an increasing number of students who can climb the hill faster than I can!) We came down the far side and collected beautiful petrified wood (with tree rings and worm-holes or ant-holes well preserved) so everyone picked as many pieces as they could carry in their arms. It was several miles back to the vehicles, however, so the trail was marked by pieces of petrified wood. I still have the 3 pieces I brought back along with an unusual gizzard-stone(?).
The small groups drove the vehicles back to PA after Glacier, while Rob went back to the camp on Little Sheep Creek (a bear had raided it once we had left!). Our van (Mitch, Bob, Dave, and I) drove north from Glacier National Park into Canada, detouring far enough west to "set foot" in British Columbia and to see some spectacular folds before heading back east to Medicine Hat and then straight across southern Canada to Winnipeg, then south into the USA and across the northern peninsula of Michigan, then south to the Turnpike and back to PA. [DHE: This short side trip gained some notoriety in later years and has now reached legendary status.]
I know that Rob taught the 1962 camp in the same area, and I believe that he also taught the 1964 and 1961 camps there as well.
Of all the faculty members at PSU, Rob and his field camp had the greatest impact on me. Dick Jahns and Lauren Wright were also quite important to me. That 6-weeks camp in one area really gives people the time to learn how to map, and those principles can then be applied to any area and any rocks. Having since mapped some 40-50 7.5-minute quadrangles in many different types of rocks, I know that initial long period of time in one area was more important than a variety of short projects in different rock types. Of course most camps today don't operate that way, including YBRA.
Some additional comments by Lynn Brant on the 1963 field camp
I was at the Penn State summer camp among the Lima Peaks in 1962 as a student and 1963 as a student instructor. I also popped in several times in 1964 when Oscar Huh and I were working on limestones in Idaho.
Yes, I read Jerry's piece. He tells it pretty well. There were a couple points I remember slightly differently. The guy who got sick and spent a night or two in Idaho Falls was Don Kelly who was in my class but who worked in Greenland the summer of 62 and took summer camp in 63. I was with him in Idaho Falls that weekend he was sick, and we watched a partial eclipse of the sun from the hotel window.
Lynn's comments about the previous year's field camp
Lynn Brant remembers about the 1962 field camp.... most of this narrative is from an article in the Fall 2005 Earth News from the Department of Earth Science, University of Northern Iowa
Geology field camp, as any old geologist will tell you, can be quite adventurous, sometimes even educational. My experience in 1962 was like that.
After a spring field course of mapping and measuring sections in a Pennsylvania quarry, five of us piled into a brand new International Travelall, the mother of all SUVs, and headed to Montana to see the real thing. The five of us made it, but the Travelall didn't. It was a nice, straight portion of a South Dakota highway. I totaled the vehicle and sent Nan to the hospital in Pierre. A few days later, we retrieved Nan and resumed our travels in other vehicles of the Penn State caravan. Nan carried a 40-pound backpack that summer with her recovering collar bone which was broken in the accident. Tough woman!
Nan's roommate during her two days in the hospital was Florence Williams, the wife of a rancher, who, I think, had fallen off a ladder. When we came home we stopped at their ranch and had a nice visit. Their place was near a former town site called Wendt. Dick Williams was kind of a show-off. He pretended to be a big drinker, fast in his cars, and all the rest you would associate with a cowboy. Actually, it wasn't a show -- he really was that sort of guy!! But he was likeable. We stopped there in 1963 (maybe twice) because I got to know the Williams pretty well over the years.
We entered southwest Montana and then crossed Centennial Valley on the gravel road that nearly mired several of the vehicles. But, oh, what scenery! That was as close to heaven as I had ever been. The green valley and snowcapped mountains set in the "big sky" of Montana!
Penn State's camp was a small Forest Service campground at the end of a long, lonely road. Lima was ten miles away and the Lima Peaks rose around us. Accommodations were two persons to a tent, and the dining hall was a tarp strung over a picnic table. The nearest telephone, refrigerator, and running water were in Lima. The nearest grocery store and fresh meat were in Dillon, some 40 or 50 miles away. The camp managers bought food once a week in Dillon, and on that one night each week we had fresh meat, some fresh fruit, maybe some wine, and delicious strawberry pie from Skeet's Cafe. The rest of the week was kind of thin. It was that summer that I learned that two eggs for breakfast was a real luxury. We had a chance to get a shower at the Lima Hotel on Saturday, whether we needed it or not. By Friday or Saturday my socks stood up by themselves! The evening entertainment was singing ribald songs around the campfire and, of course, working on our maps.
Undergrads in camp that summer were Ron Smith (who later got his MS with Al Guber), Ed Dowling, Jim Lovejoy, Art Fuller, Al Bowser, Lynn Brant, Linda Williamson, Peter Groth, Nan Stewart, and Malcolm Stewart. Graduate students, some getting introduced to their thesis work: John Haas [PhD66], Sam Romberger [PhD68], Ivo Lucchitta [PhD67], Baerbel Koesters [PhD66], who later married Ivo and had a career with USGS/NASA, John M'Gonigal [PhD65] and his wife, and Skip Lenker [Earle S Lenker, PhD62], who had his T-bird along. There was a highschool-aged helper, Ron Bortree, Rob and Marsha Scholten, and Peter Scholten (only ten years old that summer but he was as fast up the mountains as his dad!). I think maybe Marsha was the main cook that summer. Then Lauren Wright and Ben Troxel visited for a while and went out with the students to help teach.
Before going west in 62, one of the veterans from 1961 advised me to always be first up a mountain (to demonstrate enthusiasm). I tried! But Rob was fast and his wife and son were faster. There were several times I headed up the hill as fast as I could go, and even though I was the first of the students, I was met by the Scholten family on the top! Once we were some distance from the vehicles when Rob finished his lecture and the whole group headed back. I decided to be first but Rob was ahead of me. Neither of us admitted to being in a race but that we were. He beat me but I gave him a good run!!
We worked in teams of two, and each team was responsible for mapping a designated area. Al was my partner, and we mapped a 28-square-mile expanse of mostly Mesozoic sedimentary rocks on the south side of the Lima Peaks. To reach the area each day we drove a 1948 Jeep (just like the ones used on MASH, except ours was a faded maroon color) to Lima, down the paved road at 40 mph (because that was its top speed) and then several miles across ranch land to where we started our walk of up to seven miles to reach the far corner of our area. We mapped on air photos. There were no topographic maps for that part of Montana in 1962.
One day Al and I tried approaching our area by crossing the mountain. We got the Jeep up to a grassy meadow near a sheepherder's wagon. Then we started across the talus toward a saddle on a ridge. I thought I heard water running, but because we were on boulders on the side of a steep mountain, I couldn't figure out where the water was coming from. Then I noticed that I heard it only when I took a step. Holy Smokes!!! The whole side of the mountain was slowly moving down slope with every step! Surrounded by big boulders and with a cliff below us, I realized that if we started a rock slide they wouldn't even know where to look for our remains! We quickly got off the slope and returned to the Jeep, shaken but alive. No geology done that day!
When the course ended, the five of us who had been in the ill-fated Travelall started home together. My companions were Pete, Linda, Nan and Malcolm, plus a ground squirrel in a cage. Malcolm and I had decided to grow a beard that summer, at a time when nobody grew beards. Pete was clean-shaven: to impress Linda, I suspect. Malcolm was married to Nan, so he wasn't trying to impress anyone. We left Lima in a Plymouth station wagon that had been seriously abused that summer by one of the grad students (always blame the grad students). We made it to Butte by nightfall, where we tried to turn around in a school and found we had no working transmission. (I swear, I wasn't driving that time!!) We were stuck on the edge of a town that had a reputation for being rough. Besides, the copper miners in Butte had gone on strike that very day. But we were tough. We had just spent a summer in the mountains of Montana and we had our sleeping bags. No problem. The police didn't see it that way in the middle of the night, though. We had to explain why we were sleeping in the school yard and why we were driving a vehicle registered to The Pennsylvania State University. Our beards and the caged squirrel didn't help matters. Neither did the fact that Pete was in his underwear as he locked up the car again. "You get some pants on before daylight. You're in a residential area young man!" said the cop.
It took two days to fix the transmission, but in the era of sending checks through the mail we waited for six days before the garage would let us go. Meanwhile we checked into an old hotel in downtown Butte for only $5.00 a night for all five of us, six counting the squirrel. For that we got a parlor, a bedroom, and a bathroom with a tub, as long as we promised not to sleep in the bed. So we rolled out our sleeping bags, placed the squirrel on the fireplace mantle and went to sleep. Money was short. We made a rule that if you couldn't eat it or read it you didn't buy it! We ate for five nights in a row in the three Chinese restaurants in town because Nan thought we could get the most food for our buck that way.
After Butte we traveled to Glacier National Park and home to Pennsylvania through Billings, Montana, and Iowa. Coming down the long hill into Billings from the rimrocks we heard on the radio "Ramblin Rose" by Nat King Cole for the first time. Every time I hear that song I think of that sunny, hot day in August so many years ago.
There were other adventures that summer, like the time the sheriff and I went up that lonely road with a loaded 30-30, which we figured we might have to use (and not on a bear!). But as everyone knows, there are some stories from field camp best left untold. Within a few years Pete and Linda got married, Nan and Malcolm got divorced, and Al married my sister. And I lived happily ever after.
An essay by Don Kelly on the Wild Cow Milking Contest, with comments by Ed Beutner, Rob Scholten, and Jerry Bartholomew
A version of Don Kelly's story, My First Wild Cow, appeared in the March/April 2008 issue of The Penn Stater alumni magazine (p. 13), accompanied by this illustration by Martin Jarrie
Ed Beutner, Rob Scholten, and Don Kelly on the Wild Cow Milking Contest
ED BEUTNER: "I was working in Idaho, but I remember driving over to Lima to meet to spend the 4th of July with the field camp group and the other grad students (Baerbel Luchitta, Oscar Huh, Bob Ryder) who had gathered. To uphold the honor of Penn State, several of the group (fortunately not including me) entered the wild cow milking contest at the local rodeo, an event which required consumption of a lot of beer by all of us beforehand. This event involved a team of three being given a rope at the other end of which was a range cow. The goal was to get a perceptible amount of milk from the cow into a Coke bottle. The cow, on her part, tried to drag the trio face down across the arena through the dirt and cow poop"
A LETTER TO THE EDITOR OF THE SUMMER COLLEGIAN, July 18, 1963, entitled "Geologists Defend University's Honor":
"Who says students are getting soft? Not those at the Penn State Geology Camp in Montana!
This is to inform you that, at the Lima, Montana, rodeo the PSU Wild Cow Milking Team, consisting of Lynn Brant, Don Kelly and Mitch Smith, wrestled the maddest, snortingest, stampingest, bellowing range cow these parts have seen in many a year, held her fast by head and tail, and milked her to deafening applause in the stands in 52 seconds flat!
True, they didn't win, but they did beat several teams of life-long husky cowpokes. I figure the folks back East would want to know that Penn State's honor is being properly defended in the woolly West!
------ Robert Scholten, Associate Professor of Geology"
My First Wild Cow for Dear Old State
Or, Take one wild cow, add pop bottle and spit
by Donovan Kelly
I hadn't thought about that wild cow, the one I attacked with a pop bottle, in a long time. I mean, who thinks much about the summer of 1963 these days? Shoot, I have trouble remembering last summer.
But there I was, in the middle of a vanity search, looking to see where Google might find my name on the web, when my summer of 63 popped up. Who would have thought that Penn State had a web page just for the summer geology field camp program? Or that my 1963 field camp in Montana would have its own page and include a fleeting reference to me and my first wild cow?
It was not love at first sight. It was war. The honor of all easterners was at stake. We saw how the good old boys of Montana looked at us. We saw them in their tall boots, jeans and long-sleeve shirts laughing at our shorts and tee shirts.
Maybe they thought we were after their women, but all we wanted was their geology. Just enough to fill our map, write a report and pass a class that had kept us on the road for 6 weeks. This was my last class before graduation and I already had a real job waiting for me. Geophysical Services Inc. had promised me a return to the Arctic and an assignment on the North Slope of Alaska. (What I got was West Texas, Louisiana, Saudi Arabia and Kuwait.)
Before we could map Montana geology and drink local beer, we had to first win acceptance from the locals. Our leader, Dr. Scholten, said winning over the locals was an important lesson for all geologists to learn. You can look it up in my notes. Little did I know that I would spend 30 years at USGS doing just that, working with the news media to try and make the world safer for geologists.
I think it was Dr. Scholten himself who suggested that we enter the local Lima rodeo to earn goodwill and show them we were just regular people. Or maybe it was the devil himself who suggested it, thinking he would get a good laugh. Both got their laughs, and both were smart enough not to enter themselves.
For a number of reasons, we passed up bull riding. In fact, the only event we were remotely qualified for was the wild cow milking contest. As fate would have it, I was the only student present who had actually milked anything before. Most of my milking experience had been with goats, but one summer I did dabble in cows. But what we faced was not those gentle Pennsylvania milking cows strapped in a barn and munching hay. These were free-roaming cows fresh off the range that had never had any friendly human contact. Mama cows who were extra frantic because they were looking for their lost calves and whose udders were painfully swollen.
Did I mention that these 800-pound cows were running loose in an arena and being hooted on by the locals? My teammates, Lynn Brant and Mitch Smith, were to hold the cow still enough and long enough, for me to get some milk into a tight-lipped Coke bottle. "Got to see some color," the judges explained.
Our cow never got what I would call still, but I did manage to squirt some milk into the bottle and went racing back to the judges. I think we came in second. The judge looked at my cow-trodden and plop-plastered feet and proud grin and then at the bottle. "Looks like real milk," he said. "Most people know enough to just spit in the bottle."
Maybe it was a put down, but at least we were able to drink beer with the locals after that. And next time, I'll just spit in the bottle.
(P. S. Yes, I'm the one who got sick and spent a week in the Lima railroad hotel with Goldie who made me oatmeal and sent daily updates to my mother. Sorry, Lynn, I don't remember the partial eclipse. Just an excess of train whistles and oatmeal. After recovering, I stayed over at field camp after the other undergraduates left to finish my geology report. I ended up hitchhiking back to Pennsylvania. Rest of the story will cost you a beer. Send it to donovan@donovanwrites.com). [Don's website <http://donovanwrites.com/> includes excerpts from his book "Quest for the Holy Grill: 50 Crummy But Good Restaurants Within Rambling Range of Washington, D.C." The picture accompanying this piece, showing the correct way to eat corn, was originally published with a story in The Washington Post and appears on his website.]
And an addendum from Jerry Bartholomew: Since I was not at the Rodeo, your "hands on" experience is important for people to appreciate the extent to which the field camp folks tried to blend in with the locals. In that same spirit, I don't know if you remember or not, but there was also a dance at the schoolhouse in Monida (south of Lima a few miles on I-15) that at least some of us went to. That old school house was not in too bad of shape in 1983 when I moved to Butte, where I lived and worked for a decade, but it is now in ruins.
Leonard (Bob) Gardner's recollections of Herm and the Bug
Gypsum beds in Oklahoma. To the right: Herm Witte and The Bug. Photo courtesy of David Reidenour
Bob Gardner recalls Herm and the Bug at the 1963 camp
I read Jerry Bartholomew's recollections of the 1963 field camp. He refers to a tall skinny grad student with thick glasses who ate wheat germ. This was Herman Witte. He was from Trenton NJ and did a MS in Geology at Penn State. I believe that he then went to the University of Alabama to study psychiatry but have since lost track of him. Just before we started out on the cross-country geology tour, Herm's mother bought him a brand new Volkswagon Bug. A day or so later the carravan was camping somewhere in southern Ohio. The next morning Herm announced that he had to take his Bug in to have its 500 mile checkup. Larry Lattman, who was leading that leg of the tour, said "God damn it Herm, we can't wait for you to take your car in for service!" So off we went minus Herm. Several days later we were riding the dirt back roads of southwestern Missouri to meet a mining geologist who was going to show us the lead-zinc deposits of that area. Suddenly up ahead we saw a yellow Bug making circles in the road. It was Herm! " How the hell did you ever find us out here?" Well it turned out that Herm had stopped at a restaurant on US 66 in Joplin the night before and by pure chance had met the geologist who we were going to meet the next day.
Herm pulled off another similar stroke of good luck several days later in Carlsbad NM. We were staying in a KOA campground and on Sunday morning had gone out to see the Caverns. We came back around noon to have lunch and a short siesta. At about 2PM the caravan set off to tour a potash mine just west of Carlsbad. At the mine we boarded an elevator and went down about a thousand feet to the potash workings. From there we walked about a mile along one of the drifts and then noticed that Herm and Dave Reidenour were not with us. Later, as our host was discussing the geochemical origin of the deposits and the mining methods used to extract them, we heard voices coming down the drift. And then into our midst came Herm and Dave, unescorted. They had overslept and missed the caravan. So they set out into the dessert in the Bug looking for us in one of a dozen or so mines in the area. As luck would have it they stumbled upon the right mine, and the elevator operator sent them down with instructions as to which drift to follow.
Unfortunately Herm's luck ran out later in Montana. One morning, while driving to his map area, he hit a boulder that had rolled onto the road and had to be towed into Lima for repairs.
Click on the thumbnails to enlarge the images: (The first five images are from 1963, thanks to David Reidnour, in addition to the lead photo on the 1963 recollections page and the lead photo on the Herm and Bug page. The other photos were taken in the 1980s and a few in 2009 by Jerry Bartholomew.)
Alumni Field Camp 1963 Photos
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|